Amish Thimble Cookies, Plus Several Life Lessons

Jayca Pike 01/07/2014

In Which I Discover That Simple Pleasures Can Require Hard Work

Most people, myself included, equate the Amish lifestyle with simplicity — and for good reason. Their oral histories (or those histories as disseminated by mainstream society) are filled with proverbs that speak to plain and honest principles:

“Peace is seeing a sunset, and knowing whom to thank.”


That’s a beautiful little piece of happiness to carry around in your pocket, don’t you think? Instead of seeing a sunset and wondering where my camera phone is, what filter to use on the sunset photo, which social platform to send it to . . .

I digress.

This past Sunday, I was inspired to bake some Amish simplicity into my life with a batch of Thimble Cookies (or Thumbprint Cookies, or [adorably] Bird’s Nest Cookies). You’re welcome to download the Amish Thimble Cookie recipe here, and it’s also posted below.

A few things to note:

1. “A task takes as long as it takes.”

After making the world’s absolute most sticky dough ever, I chilled it in the fridge for an hour, per my mother’s sage advice. After attempting to roll several more cookies, I was still losing half of the dough in my palms.

A total of four hours in the fridge resulted in workable dough. I blame the Florida humidity!

2. “You can’t make good hay from poor grass.”

I used sugar-free, off-brand jam. The baked result was a batch of cute little cookies floating in a sea of blueberry and cherry goo, which later cooled to Goo SuperGlue. I was scraping cookie-crumble-dotted jam-crust from baking pans (and, ahem, nibbling it) for the rest of the evening. In truth? An excellent snack in front of Sunday Night television — like Fruit Roll-Ups with cookie bits!

3. “Watch a person as a cat does a mouse.”

Do not underestimate the deliciousness of these sweet nothings. They’re plain enough for dunking, tasty enough to eat alone, and deceptively light. While changing camera lenses, I lost a good half-dozen to my significant other, who happily shrugged and noted that the recipe had made plenty to photograph, and plenty more to serve at work on Monday.

I noted that my coworkers finished them by noon 🙂

Please enjoy — let me know if you try these, or if you have any secrets on perfecting the process!


Amish Thimble Cookies Recipe



Related Posts
Amish Chocolate Cake Recipe

I've got a sweet tooth. If someone offers me something sweet, it's hard for me to say "no." When I walk Read more

Outdoor Furniture Ideas for the Autumn Season!

Take the chill out of the 'Ber months with these cozy outdoor furniture concepts! Time to welcome shorter days and Read more

Recipe-Inspired Two-Tone Beds

Because Nothing is Better than Breakfast in Bed (or, you know, desert . . . ) With Autumn baking season Read more

Labor Day Menu: Down-Home Cooking 5
Chicken Sweet-Corn Soup

Consider this feast a Labor Day labor of love. Next up: Chicken Sweet-Corn Soup, straight from Pennsylvania Dutch Country! Chicken Read more

About the Author

One comment

  • Linse Miller
    July 3, 2014 at 12:50 pm

    They were delicious Jayca! I love, love, love this proverb – “Peace is seeing a sunset, and knowing whom to thank.”

    Thank you for sharing the recipe, cookies and reflection!

Leave a Reply