Best Amish Fireplaces for 2025
Over the past few years, electric fireplaces have begun to overtake gas fireplaces in popularity. There are many reasons why the tides have turned.
Electric fireplaces are eco-friendly, safer, more customizable, easier to maintain, cheaper to buy, and more affordable to install!
- Eco-Friendly: Amish electric fireplaces are environmentally friendly. Our Amish fireplaces are made from sustainably sourced wood and have zero emissions with a reduced carbon footprint!
- Safety: Amish electric fireplaces are safer to use with no real flames or combustible gas. You don’t have to worry about any people, children, or pets getting scolded by the hot surfaces of real fireplaces.
- Customizable: You can control the color tones and flame sizes.
- Cheaper: Amish fireplaces cost less, are easy to install, and only add a few dollars to your electric bill! Check out our electric fireplace cost calculator to see what it will cost you.
Electric fireplaces continue to dominate in 2025 due to their modern functionality, eco-friendliness, and sleek, solid-wood designs. This year’s top picks showcase not only the innovative features customers love but also Amish craftsmanship, premium materials, and styles that fit every home.
Electric Fireplace Trends in 2025
Before we dive into the best Amish fireplaces for 2025, let’s take a look at a few of the current trends we have found through our analysis.
Electric Fireplace Trends for 2025
- Natural and Rustic Styles: Homeowners are prioritizing natural wood finishes (which happens to be our most popular finish for our most popular wood type) and organic designs that connect their indoor spaces to nature.
- Space Efficiency and Multifunctionality: As living spaces shrink, compact and multifunctional furniture, like corner fireplaces and portable units, are on the rise.
- Eco-Friendly and Cost-Effective Heating: Eco-conscious buyers prefer electric fireplaces for their low energy consumption and lack of harmful emissions.
- Statement Pieces: Large, ornate fireplaces are making a comeback for homeowners who have large spaces.
Best Rustic Log Amish Electric Fireplace With Mantel for 2025
The Amish Rustic Log Electric Fireplace Mantel is built with solid wooden logs and has captivating live edges.
- Features:
- This piece has a stunning live edge design, choice of wood type (aspen, rustic pine, red cedar), and plenty of mantel space for decor. Dovetailed drawer boxes are an indicator of eminence.
- Why It’s the Best:
- This fireplace emits warmth and comfort in its natural beauty, capturing the essence of the forest through the solid log construction. It also emits warmth with its Classic Flame electric fireplace insert. This piece is an eye-catcher and heats up to 1,000 sq. ft.
- In 2025, natural wood finishes are a top trend for bringing warmth and a connection to nature into the home. The live edge detail on this fireplace makes it a standout for homeowners who want a rustic yet luxurious feel.
- Perfect For:
- This fits great for those seeking a centerpiece fireplace for traditional or rustic homes. The natural logs complement rooms with bricks, stone, reclaimed barn wood, and mounted hunting trophies. It’s also an eclectic way to add a rustic element of nature to a contemporary room.
- Unique Touch:
- This fireplace comes standard with soft-close drawers. The use of real wooden logs sets this fireplace apart from the rest.
- Fireplace Insert: Classic Flame
- Watts: 1,500
- Heating Range: 1,000 sq. ft.
Best Amish Corner Electric Fireplace for 2025
The Amish Charleston Hardwood Corner Electric Fireplace was one of our top overall electric fireplaces in 2024 and is set to be highly sought after in 2025. This fireplace has a classic aesthetic that fits both modern and traditional decors.
- Features:
- This fireplace features a space-saving corner design, 1500-watt infrared heater, and fully customizable wood and stain options.
- Why It’s the Best:
- It commands attention with standout solid wood construction. It is presented in several different hardwoods and finishes with a design built to highlight the beauty of the natural wood grain.
- Perfect For:
- This fits perfectly in a small apartment or a room with limited wall space. Corner electric fireplaces have efficient, space-saving designs! But this beautiful Amish masterpiece will make its mark in any sized room!
- In 2025, efficient use of space is critical as more homeowners look for furniture that maximizes functionality in compact rooms. The corner design is perfect for small apartments or homes with unique layouts.
- Its fully customizable wood options make it not just a fireplace, but a personalized piece of art that fits seamlessly into any decor.
- Unique Touch:
- This piece shows off the wood constructions and expert craftsmanship that is synonymous with Amish fireplaces. It may sit off in the corner of your room, but it stands out as the center of attention.
- Fireplace Insert: Classic Flame
- Watts: 1,500
- Heating Area: 1,000 sq. ft.
Best Small Electric Amish Fireplace for 2025
The Amish Portable Wall Mantel with Electric Fireplace Heater on Casters is perfect for keeping small spaces warm and cozy. The hidden casters make it easy to move around the room.
- Features:
- Standing a diminutive 26″ high and 12″ deep, this Amish fireplace is one of the smallest solid wood electric fireplaces on the market. The compact design and the addition of the hidden casters allow for extremely convenient mobility without sacrificing any heating power!
- Why It’s the Best:
- It is very portable due to its small size and casters on the bottom. Despite its small stature, this fireplace still has a 1,000 ft. heating area, matching many larger models.
- Portable electric fireplaces are in high demand in 2025 as homeowners seek versatile furniture that adapts to changing room layouts and needs.
- Perfect For:
- Hidden casters and a compact design make this model perfect for renters or those who like to rearrange their furniture frequently, like my wife, or her sister, or my mother, or… pretty much every woman I’ve ever met.
- Unique Touch:
- It’s unique qualities include hidden casters for secret portability and a solid wood mantel on top for displaying decorations or photos.
- Fireplace Insert: Classic Flame
- Watts: 1,500
- Heating Area: 1,000 sq. ft.
Best Large Electric Amish Fireplace for 2025
The Amish 76″ Solid Wood Wall Mantel with Electric Fireplace is 77% taller than our best small fireplace for 2025. This fireplace is designed to bring majesty, light, and warmth to a large living room or an open-concept home. This is a grandiose statement piece.
- Features:
- This fireplace includes a wide mantel design with customizable finishes, powerful 1500-watt infrared heating, and advanced flame controls.
- Why It’s the Best:
- In 2025, large statement pieces are trending as open-concept living spaces remain popular. This fireplace not only fills a room with warmth but also commands attention with its impressive 76-inch width.
- Perfect For:
- This piece is designed for larger living rooms, dens, or open-plan spaces. The elegant design and details are perfect for a formal decor style.
- Unique Touch:
- The ornate wood design and acrylic solid surface add a touch of sophistication that’s perfect for formal living rooms or grand entertaining spaces.
- Fireplace Insert: Classic Flame
- Watts: 1,500
- Heating Area: 1,000 sq. ft.
Best Amish TV Stand with Electric Fireplace for 2025
TV stands always look better with an electric fireplace. Check out our full selection of Amish TV Stands with Electric Fireplaces. Modern minimalism is popular right now. People are looking for premium-quality furniture with contemporary styles.
The Amish Maple Wood Custom Modern Media Console brings the best of both worlds in 2025. Take a gander at the beautiful maple media console below. You may think you need to clean the lenses of your glasses or adjust the antennae. Your eyes do not deceive you.
- Features:
- This fireplace stands out with a contemporary design, loads of customizable options, and premium construction.
- Why It’s the Best:
- This piece is highly customizable. The electric fireplace insert needs to be selected in the options, it does not come as a standard feature. But the depth of customizable options is mind-boggling.
- Perfect For:
- This piece maximizes space efficiency with a modern style. With the rise of multifunctional furniture in 2025, this TV stand with an optional electric fireplace is a must-have for modern living rooms.
- Unique Touch:
- If you select the 76 1/4″ wide version with the electric fireplace option, it comes standard with the wine storage!
- Fireplace Insert: Classic Flame
- Watts: 1,500
- Heating Area: 1,000 sq. ft.
Summary of the Best Electric Fireplaces for 2025
| Fireplace | Key Features | Perfect For | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rustic Log Amish Fireplace | Live edge design, solid wood, 1,000 sq. ft. heating | Rustic and traditional homes | $$$ |
| Charleston Corner Fireplace | Space-saving, customizable, classic look | Apartments and small spaces | $$ |
| Portable Wall Mantel Fireplace | Hidden casters, compact size | Small spaces, flexibility | $ |
| Large 76″ Wall Mantel Fireplace | Wide design, ornate details | Open-plan or formal living spaces | $$$$ |
| TV Stand with Electric Fireplace | Multi-functional, optional wine storage | Modern and stylish entertainment areas | $$ |
Watch: Amish Fireplace in Action
More Amish Electric Fireplace Resources from DutchCrafters
- Electric Fireplaces
- TV Stands with Electric Fireplaces
- Entertainment Centers With Electric Fireplaces
- How Much Electricity Does an Electric Fireplace Use?
- Electric Fireplace Cost Calculator
- 10 Common Questions About Amish Electric Fireplaces
- Space Saver: The Corner Fireplace
- Caring for Your Electric Fireplace: Maintenance and Tips
Why the Dimplex Electric Fireplace Insert is a Favorite Among Amish Craftsmen It's no surprise you will find the Dimplex Read more
Fireplaces are as visually pleasing as the warmth and comfort they emit in your room on a cold night. Gas Read more
Many of our Amish builders use the Classic Flame Electric Fireplace Insert for their Amish fireplaces. Today, we will get Read more
Based on the average electricity cost in America, a standard 1,500-watt electric fireplace will cost $0.27 per hour. The precise Read more
Seth Carter has been with DutchCrafters since 2020. Seth has won multiple awards for his work in Amish furniture while with DutchCrafters. He has advised and partnered with more than 150 Amish wood shops on furniture presentation, design, industry trends, product options, and the development of exclusive products. He is originally from Indiana and even lived in Amish country (LaGrange, Indiana) for an extended period of time while working with DutchCrafters. He contributes to the Timber to Table Blog and has written content throughout the DutchCrafters website. Seth has a B.S. in Business Administration from IU-East and has owned Carter Family Insurance, LLC. since 2014.
