Cherry vs. Maple: Does One Make Better Wood Furniture?

Beth Rice 28/01/2021

There’s a lot to know about wood types when it comes to building custom wood furniture. Durability, color, cost and features should all be considered before selecting a wood type for your new table, bed, desk or chair.

Two wood types, both quite popular in their own right, are cherry wood and maple wood. When it comes to cherry vs maple, does one make better wood furniture?

Let’s take a look.

First we have cherry wood, one of the most popular and sought after wood types for solid wood furniture. Most of us have heard of cherry’s elegance and durability, along with the red hues and the fascinating darkening cherry wood does over time with exposure to light.

Amish Oleta Dining Chair
The Amish Oleta Dining Chair in cherry wood with burnt umber stain.

Then there’s maple, both brown maple and hard maple. The maples have smooth wood grain like cherry. Brown maple in particular offers versatility and strength, while hard maple stuns with its light shades, hardness and powerful strength.

Amish Hammond Single Pedestal Dining Table
The Amish Hammond Single Pedestal Dining Table in brown maple wood with nutmeg stain.

Why do we compare them? There are similarities between cherry and brown maple in particular that are noteworthy. It has been said that brown maple mimics cherry with its smooth grain. With brown maple costing less, can you get the look of cherry for less?  The differences between the two showcase different capabilities that are also important to note, since they may limit what you can do as far as staining or painting.

Amish 36 Vienna Bookcase with Optional Doors
The Amish 36″ Vienna Bookcase with Optional Doors in hard maple wood with natural stain.

Facts About Cherry Wood

Changes in Color

While cherry has a fine texture and uniform appearance, its color can vary. Many are drawn to cherry’s exquisite reddish-brown hues. Cherry wood is actually a pale color when first cut, but it’s famous for its slow darkening over time when exposed to light, which turns the wood a rich brown red shade. This natural darkening generates lots of interest in cherry furniture. It’s also something that owners must pay attention to in order to see that darkening occurs evenly. That’s why it’s important where you place your cherry furniture as consideration must be taken to where all or portions of the furniture could be exposed to light.

Amish Fur Elise Rolling Pin Bed
The Amish Fur Elise Rolling Pin Bed in cherry wood with Washington finish.

Cherry’s grain pattern is rich and smooth. Some features you will find in cherry wood are small dark spots, flecks and mineral deposits (places where sap was stored at one time). It may contain pith flecks (worm tracks that create brown streaks) and pit pockets. Cherry furniture is elegant and exudes warmth.

Durability

While cherry is a softer hardwood, it is durable and a great choice for ornate chair or table styles. Even though cherry is a slightly softer variety of hardwood, it’s one you can trust to stay strong. It can however, sustain nicks and dents more easily than other hardwoods, so owners of cherry furniture should take care that it is protected.

Finishing Cherry

Woodworkers like cherry because it has a uniform grain with a fine smooth texture and they can easily shape it and work with it to create exquisite carvings and turnings. In addition, cherry polishes nicely.

Amish Queen Anne Highboy Dresser
The Amish Queen Anne Highboy Dresser in cherry wood with Cordovan finish.

Cherry can be stained in a variety of light or dark stain choices, or it can be left in a natural finish. Cherry makes stunning dining room tables and is just the right choice for formal and traditional styles as well as transitional ones that blend traditional and contemporary.

Cherry Pros

  • Darkens with age
  • Easy to shape and polish
  • Exquisite color
  • Durable
  • Makes exquisite formal and traditional style furniture

Cherry Cons

  • Darkens with age
  • A bit softer than other hardwoods, more prone to dings and dents with heavy use
  • It’s expensive

The Case for Brown Maple Wood

Brown Maple Colors

Brown maple often resembles the look of cherry wood. It contains combinations of browns, tans and creams with varying light to dark streaks that create unique patterns.  It can contain some pitch fleck (where insects have carved out tunnels) or mineral streeks. Variations in brown maple wood also include birds eye which is sought after for its unique look. It’s called birds eye because the pattern looks like small swirls with eyes.

Amish Ellington Dining Chair
The Amish Ellington Dining Chair in brown maple wood with Autumn leaf stain.

Durability

Like cherry, brown maple is a softer hardwood. It’s durable, but may sustain nicks or dents a bit more easily than other hardwoods like oak.

Finishing Brown Maple

Brown maple takes stains and paints well, and its smooth grain makes it a highly versatile wood choice, fitting both casual and formal furniture styles. Brown maple furniture can be stained with light or dark stains, but it works best in dark stains. It’s possible to have some greenish mineral streaking in brown maple wood and this could show with a light stain. With a dark stain, the streaks add to a unique look, with some areas of the wood appearing darker than others.

Brown Maple is the go to wood choice for furniture you want to paint, because of its sleek, smooth wood grain and uniform texture. These qualities also make it an ideal wood for distressing to create an antique look. It’s easy to cut and shape, and therefore can be used for different furniture styles.

Amish Vienna Coffee Table
The Amish Vienna Coffee Table in brown maple wood with driftwood stain.

Brown maple costs less because it is a common wood that grows quickly. It has lots of fans because it’s similar to cherry but doesn’t cost as much.

Amish Hampton Cannon Ball Poster Bed
The Amish Hampton Cannon Ball Poster Bed in brown maple wood with onyx dark brown stain.

Brown Maple Pros

  • Smooth grain makes it suitable to stain or paint, opening up more options
  • Durable
  • Gorgeous in dark stains
  • One of the least expensive hardwood options, costs less than cherry
  • Mineral streaking creates unique pattern when stained with some areas darker than others

Brown Maple Cons

  • Softer hardwood so more prone to scratches and denting with heavy use
  • Looks better in dark stains due to mineral streaking in the wood
Amish Large Corner Curio Cabinet
The Amish Large Corner Curio Cabinet in brown maple wood with Bing cherry stain.

Have You Heard About Hard Maple?

Hard Maple Color

Hard maple comes from the sapwood (outer rings) of the tree. It’s light in color, offering a gorgeous natural look. The pores of hard maple are less visible, which creates a smoother surface.

Durability

Hard maple is a strong wood, one of the hardest domestic woods, and it’s denser, heavier and harder than brown maple, making it ideal for furniture that gets heavy use. It absorbs shock and resists wear. Hard maple makes great butcher blocks, pool cue shafts and wooden baseball bats.

Finishing Hard Maple

Loved for its hardness, light colors and smooth grain, hard maple can be stained or painted. It’s very attractive in a natural stain, tung oil or linseed oil that brings out the unique qualities in the wood grain.

Hard Maple Pros

  • Very strong wood, highly durable
  • Attractive natural color
  • Resists warping and twisting

Hard Maple Cons

  • Costs a little more than brown maple

In Summary

Both cherry and brown maple are hardwoods of a “softer” nature.  They are still plenty durable for strong wood furniture with a Janka rating of 950 for brown maple and a 950 for cherry too. Hard maple has a Janka hardness rating of 1450.

Hawthorn Amish Side Dining Chair
The Hawthorn Amish Side Dining Chair in brown maple wood with rich tobacco stain.

While brown maple costs less and features a smooth grain, it does not have the unique darkening element cherry offers. It also looks better in darker stains or paints due to its mineral streaks, and the stain may appear darker in some areas than others.

Cherry is more expensive, but earns its price with its smooth grain and rich cherry shades, as well as its even display of stain and its ability to be carved into detailed shapes.

Amish Royal Mission Computer Desk
The Amish Royal Mission Computer Desk in cherry wood with natural finish.

Hard maple displays light colors, looks gorgeous in a natural finish, and can handle heavy use. What do you think? Is cherry, brown maple or hard maple the right wood choice for your furniture?

Related Posts
Meet the Maples: Facts About Brown Maple

Here at DutchCrafters we deal with a lot of maple, brown maple wood in particular. The maple family, while beautiful, Read more

Wood Types: What is your Furniture Made Of?

Solid wood furniture has a leg up on the competition. Sought after for its quality and beauty, it can't be Read more

The Benefits of Solid Wood Furniture

I enjoy a good bargain, sure. During one of our community yard sales, I remember taking a walk around the Read more

A Quality Finish For Solid Wood Furniture: What Is Catalyzed Conversion Varnish?

We’ve heard it straight from our Amish craftsmen--finish either makes a product or breaks a product. When it comes to Read more

About the Author

Leave a Reply